Free or paid cookie banner? What you really lose with free plans

calendar_today July 5, 2026
Free or paid cookie banner? What you really lose with free plans

"Is a free cookie banner good enough?" is one of the questions we get most often. The honest answer is: it depends on what your site does and on what happens the day the data protection authority, or a user, asks you to prove that consent was given. In this article we look at what free plans really offer, where they stop and what you risk.

What free plans offer

Almost every cookie banner service has a free plan. It is their way of getting you in. The limits are always of three kinds.

Traffic or size limits: 5,000 views a month on CookieYes, 50 subpages on Cookiebot, 1,000 sessions a month on Usercentrics, 10,000 banner views on Termly. These are thresholds a brochure site with a bit of visibility passes in a few weeks.

Feature limits: banner with the provider's branding, a single language, colours you cannot customise, manual or quarterly cookie scans, no advanced Consent Mode v2.

Proof limits: almost no free plan includes the consent log. And without a log, the banner shows the request but does not keep the answer.

The three risks of a free banner

The first risk is the burden of proof. Article 7 of the GDPR says the controller must be able to demonstrate that the data subject has consented. A banner that does not log consents leaves you without proof: in an inspection you cannot show who accepted, when and what.

The second risk is preventive blocking. Many free banners show the notice but do not stop scripts from running before the click. Google Analytics, the Meta pixel, the YouTube video load their cookies while the user is still reading the banner. For the authorities this is the same as having no banner at all.

The third risk is the exceeded limit. When visits pass the threshold, the service stops working or asks you to upgrade. If you do not notice, the site stays uncovered for weeks. If you do, you pay the subscription on terms you did not choose.

Free "do it yourself" WordPress plugins

WordPress has dozens of free cookie banner plugins. Some are well made and work. The problem is not the banner, it is everything else: no scanner telling you which cookies you really have, no cookie policy updated when you add a plugin, no correctly configured Consent Mode v2, and maintenance that falls on you. When a guideline changes, you are the one who has to notice.

When free really is enough

There is one case where you need none of this: a site that uses no trackers. No Analytics, no pixels, no embedded videos, no maps, no chat. Only technical cookies, which need no consent. In that case a clear notice is enough and no banner is needed. If in doubt, Konsento's free scanner tells you in 30 seconds what your site loads before consent: konsento.cloud/en/verifica-conformita.

Be careful though: adding a YouTube video or Google Analytics is enough to leave this case.

The third way: pay once

Between the free plan with its limits and the annual subscription that renews forever there is a third option: the one-time payment. With Konsento you pay 86 euros once for each domain and everything is included: a banner that follows the regulator's guidelines, preventive script blocking, automatic scanner, searchable and exportable consent log, generated privacy and cookie policy, Google Consent Mode v2, banner in six languages. No traffic limit, no branding to remove, no renewal.

It costs less than one year of almost every subscription, and after the first year it costs nothing.

A two-minute test

Before deciding, run this check on your site:

  • Open the site in a private window and click nothing on the banner.
  • Open the browser developer tools, Application tab, Cookies section.
  • If you see cookies from Google, Meta, YouTube or other services before you have chosen, the banner is blocking nothing.
  • Look for the Reject button: it must be as visible as Accept, not hidden in a grey link.
  • Ask yourself where consents are logged. If you do not know, you are not logging them.

If even one of these answers does not convince you, free is not doing its job.

In short

A free cookie banner is fine as long as the site is small, tracks nothing and nobody asks you for proof. As soon as you use Analytics, a pixel or a video, you need preventive blocking, a scanner and a consent log, and free plans do not have them. Konsento includes them all for a one-time payment of 86 euros per domain. Try it free for 15 days: konsento.cloud/en/register.

arrow_back Torna alle News